Posts Tagged ‘legal matter’

Employment Law – Excessive Working Hours – Breach of Duty of Care

Friday, December 18th, 2009

In the case of Mark Hone v Six Continents Retail Limited (2005), a pub landlord having collapsed thanks to overwork successfully sued his former employers in the County Court for breach of duty of care.

Mr Hone, the claimant, started operating for Bass (currently Six Continents) as a pub manager in 1995 and in 1998 was awarded “Pub Manager of the Year”. But, in 1999 he started operating at The Previous Moat House where he found himself operating 13 hour days.

He repeatedly complained to his employers that he was overworked but the employers took no action. He had no assistant manager and different staff members, who left, together with 2 chefs and an administrative worker, were never replaced.

Mr Hone, who had refused to sign a clause opting out of EU legislation that limits the quantity of hours an employee works, began littered with headaches and insomnia. In Could 2000, he collapsed at work affected by an anxiety disorder. In 2004, Mr Hone sued Bass for breaching the duty of care owed to him as an employee.

The primary instance court ( Swansea County Court ) held that:

Bass had not taken cheap steps to make sure that Mr Hone failed to work over forty eight hours, that was possible to cause injury to his health, which resources online without prescription buy Camagra cheap were available to use additional support employees for him; and
Bass should pay Mr Hone £21,000 in damages.
Six Continents (formerly Bass) appealed this decision to the Court of Charm who upheld the Swansea County Court’s judgment.

Comment: This case highlights the importance of not imposing excessive operating hours on employees and making certain that employees buy Albendazole online have sufficient employees support.

© RT COOPERS, 2005. This Briefing cialis dosage daily Note does not give a comprehensive or complete statement of the law regarding order pharmacy cialis the problems discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is meant only to highlight general issues. Specialist legal advice should always be sought in relation to particular circumstances.

If you are looking for a personal injury lawyer in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury lawyer. The miami personal injury lawyer best price cialis serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal injury lawyer now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Employment Law: Time Limits for Bringing Employment Tribunal Claims

Friday, December 18th, 2009

Within the case of Chouafi v London United Busways Ltd [2005], the claimant was utilized as a bus driver by the defendant company. In October 2003, he was diagnosed with severe depression and was signed off work until February 2004. He was dismissed in January 2004 on the grounds of his medical condition and complained generic cialis 10mg to the employment tribunal of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.

The Employment Rights Act 1996 provides that an employment tribunal shall not contemplate a criticism for unfair dismissal unless it is presented to the tribunal within three months of the effective date of termination of employment.

But this 3-month limitation period might be extended if the tribunal considers that within the relevant case, it wasn’t moderately practicable for the complaint to be presented inside the three months.

There are similar provisions underneath the Incapacity Discrimination Act 1995.

The tribunal set that:-

The criticism of unfair dismissal had not been presented among the three-month limit, pursuant to s 111 of the Employment Rights Act 1996;
The criticism of disability discrimination had not been presented among the three-month closing date, pursuant to the para 3 Schedule 3 of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995; and
Accordingly, the tribunal didn’t have jurisdiction to hear the claims.
The employee appealed to the Employment Charm Tribunal (”EAT”) against the decision. The EAT held that:-

Decisions on whether or not or not a claim would be admitted out of your time, for unfair dismissal or incapacity discrimination, were essentially questions of facts on that the tribunal ought to decide based upon the evidence submitted by the parties;
The onus of proof was on the claimant to show it was not moderately cheap effects cialis practicable to bring an action among the three-month deadline;
If the claimant didn’t discharge that burden of proof, his/her case would inevitably fail;
During this case, the claimant didn’t attend the hearing and provide a lot of evidence about his mental health; and
The Tribunal was right in concluding that the worker had failed to produce an adequate explanation for filing online Camagra without prescription cheap buy his claim outside the point in time ; and
The tribunal’s decision would be upheld.
The claimant’s charm was thus dismissed.

If you need any data contact us.

© RT COOPERS, 2005. This Briefing Note does not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law referring to the issues discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is intended solely to focus on general issues. Specialist legal advice should continually be sought in relation to specific circumstances.

If you are looking for a personal injury lawyer in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury lawyer. The buy cialis online Alesse online miami personal injury lawyer serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal injury lawyer now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Employment Law: Unfair Dismissal – Constructive Dismissal – ‘Last Straw’

Friday, December 18th, 2009

The case of Bell v The Spirit Cluster Ltd [2005] concerned a claim for unfair and constructive dismissal. The employment tribunal held {that a} series of acts, by the employer, cumulatively amounted to repudiation of the worker’s contract of employment.

The employee was a manager of a national chain of pubs and restaurants. He brought a criticism of unfair constructive dismissal against his employer in the utilization tribunal on the grounds of buy cialis online failure to support him throughout a amount of a year throughout his career. He alleged that:

he had been harassed by the senior managers regarding changes to his and his wife’s single contracts to a lower-paid joint contract;
he had been bullied and his grievance initially ignored;
his grievance had been partially upheld but the bullying had continued;
the employer’s conduct amounted to a fundamental breach of his contract of employment – the implied term of mutual trust and confidence (the cause of his resignation);
his dismissal had been unfair in all the buy InnoPran XL online circumstances.
The tribunal found that, in view of the cumulative impact of the course of conduct by the employer, there had been a elementary breach of the implied term of mutual trust and confidence in the worker’s contract of employment, and it had been that breach that had been the effective reason behind the worker’s resignation. The worker’s claim of unfair tabs buy cialis constructive dismissal was upheld. The employer appealed to the Employment Attractiveness Tribunal (EAT) against that decision. The employer’s appeal was dismissed.

The EAT found that:-

the check for constructive dismissal was whether or not the employer’s conduct amounted to a repudiatory breach of the worker’s contract of employment in relation to the implied term of mutual trust and confidence;
a comparatively minor act might be sufficient to entitle the worker to resign if it was the last straw in an exceedingly series of incidents;
in this case, nothing had been done to stop the chain of causation;
the employee had regularly complained about the shortage of support, and therefore the tribunal could not be criticised as a results of its conclusions.
If you need further info contact us.

© RT COOPERS, online without prescription buy cheap Camagra 2005. This Briefing Note will not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law regarding the issues discussed nor does it represent legal advice. It’s supposed only to focus on general issues. Specialist legal recommendation should forever be sought in relation to explicit circumstances.

If you are looking for a personal injury lawyer in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury lawyer. The miami personal injury lawyer serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal cialis canadian pharmacy injury lawyer now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

How to choose an attorney?

Tuesday, December 15th, 2009

Throughout the course of your legal problems, you will have to form some robust choices – If you were concerned in an accident then you’ve got to decide on between bringing criminal damages or press with a plaintiff case, if you’ve got a tiny business and you were involved in an exceedingly deal, then you have got to make your mind up whether or not to sign it or let it pass. There is no clear-cut answer in many of those dilemmas, and getting the right lawyer is crucial to you. We tend to examine the perks of choosing a lawyer in a very pre-paid legal set up as opposed to hiring your own lawyer, and a few easy steps you can take to settle on a smart attorney.

The number one criterion has to try and do with a lawyer’s legal ability: somebody who lays the law down for you, present you with choices, make a case for the ramifications of each call you make and offer you recommendations on the most effective course of action. In this era of sophisticated legal matters, many lawyers are increasingly specialised and you stand to get higher data from online Camagra cheap buy without prescription somebody buy cialis online with a observe focus during a particular area of the law than a generalist who deals with a broad spectrum acomplia testimonials of legal issues. Building rapport is additionally very important: your relationship along with your online cialis discount lawyer will build or break your case. You would like a lawyer who offers you candid recommendation and council you’ll be able to trust, someone with enough perspective to step back from an issue and observe it from all perspectives.

Client-lawyer relationships are very restricted at intervals a pre-paid legal plan. As a result of of “preventive” nature of most plans, your contact along with your lawyer can be limited on many occasions. You seldom get to speak to your lawyer face-to-face – as most of the consultation is done over the phone – and even when you’re able to talk to them, it’s difficult to build rapport when your office consultations are restricted to a dozen hours a year.

The great news, however, is you still have some options left. Once you sign up for a legal plan, you’re able to choose your lawyer and there’s a number of steps you’ll be able to take to increase the chance of getting a good lawyer. Initial, you wish to raise for referrals from previous clients. Raise around concerning sensible attorneys in the network. Once you get a few names, check their educational background, their qualifications and their skilled data with your state’s bar association. After you receive your referrals, don’t shy far from putting in place interviews with attorneys in the network. Most don’t mind receiving enquiries about what they do and how in a position there are. ~Ask tough queries: How long have they been in apply? How happy are their previous clients? buy Breast Enlargement Patch online How many legal problems of interest to you have they taken recently?

If you are looking for a personal injury attorney in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury attorney. The miami personal injury attorney serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal injury attorney now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Differences between Pre-Paid and Legal Plans

Tuesday, December 15th, 2009

It’s not uncommon to determine the terms “legal plans” review supplier cialis and “pre-paid legal services” used interchangeably. While they share a heap of characteristics in common, there are a variety of differences you ought to remember of.

Both of those terms consult with an arrangement whereby you pay a fastened monthly or yearly fee in exchange for legal services. The idea behind them is to save customers on high legal fees while offering a valuable service. That’s where the variations lie: what sort of service is offered and what’s covered. What are you entitled to in each schemes?

Pre-paid services cover for specific legal services: buy best price cialis Tricor online free phone consultation and recommendation, drafting of simple wills and trusts, review of sample contracts and writing of letters on your behalf. Legal services not provided can get charged at regular attorney fees, however you may be eligible for discounts. Legal insurance, by distinction, works a lot of like alternative insurance plans, like health or car insurance. Although specific legal online Camagra buy without prescription cheap services are offered sometimes, your insurance supplier will sometimes provide a policy that covers for all legal services. The policy can pay on behalf of you, the policy holder, or reimburse all expenses, costs or fees that you just pay for legal services up to the policy limit. For instance, your policy would possibly reimburse any fees incurred in your court judgments or pay your bail cash – a service not provided by most pre-paid legal plans. Your legal insurance is also pegged to other insurance policies you may already have. If you run into legal issues involving your different insurance, then your legal insurance policy will defend you against loss or liability. For example, if you’re involved in an exceedingly car accident when your auto-insurance {has already} run out and you’re subsequently sued for recovery of damages, you’ll be protected by a acomplia prices legal arrange insurance. The other difference between the two schemes is connected to your alternative of attorney. In an exceedingly pre-paid legal service, you’re able to select from a restricted number of the attorneys in the network. By contrast, a legal insurance plan provides legal coverage regardless of attorney. You’re free to line up interviews with any variety of attorneys and opt for those you think that will offer the simplest service for your personal legal needs.

Finally, pre-paid legal plans are abundant a lot of accessible to the general public. Legal plans are harder to return by as solely a limited number of insurance corporations provide such arrangements.

If you are looking for a personal injury attorney in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury attorney. The miami personal injury attorney serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal injury attorney now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Common Services offered by Pre-paid legal Plans

Tuesday, December 15th, 2009

Considering a pre-paid legal plan? He’s a run-down of the services you’re possibly to induce and conjointly some legal documents you need to sign before you enrol.

Phonephone and Office Consultation: You have got unlimited telephone access to a panel of attorneys regarding any legal matter of interest to you. You’ll conjointly build transient consultation visits to your lawyer for up to 30 minutes per day at no price to you. The sole condition placed on these two advantages is that you enquire buy Oral Health Dogs online concerning a completely different legal matter. This aspect of coverage provided by legal plans is one amongst online Camagra buy cheap without prescription the most helpful because it promotes preventive law. Preventive law is terribly much like preventive medication – it helps in anticipating potential issues and taking the suitable legal steps therefore that unnecessary legal issues or risks are avoided. With a simple phone decision to your lawyer you can avoid obtaining embroiled during a hellish legal scenario, and you’ll even establish legal rights you don’t even know you had.

Follow-Up Service: The panel of lawyers will write letters and make phone calls on your behalf to adverse third parties. Such follow-up service might be all it takes to solve many of your legal problems.

Legal document review: Easy personal legal documents, like your insurance policies, sales contracts and leases can be reviewed. Any queries of legal nature that you have got about the documents will also get buy cialis online answered by your attorney.

Drafting of wills: A will could be a written document that regulates how you want your property distributed after your review cialis tabs death. Your attorney will draft your can in line with your state’s laws therefore that it’s valid when you die. He can additionally advise you on any provisions you may wish to consider, like appointing a guardian and establishing a trust.

Discount on regular fees: Any further services not covered in the written fee agreement will be at regular fees – either hourly or flat – with a discount between 20 to 30%. These services usually embody family matters, like divorce and also the custody of youngsters, and court representation, such as traffic tickets and lawsuits.

Some of the legal paperwork you need to scan rigorously, agree on and sign embody the following:

Written fee agreement: This is an agreement that outlines what services are provided in the arrange, how much it prices and also the ways of payment.

Grievance procedure: This document details the procedures that can be taken by the provide to resolve any complaints regarding attorneys or disputes regarding service fees.

If you are looking for a personal injury lawyer in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury lawyer. acomplia medication The miami personal injury lawyer serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal injury lawyer now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Benefits of Pre-paid legal plans

Tuesday, December 15th, 2009

Pre-paid legal services will be a terribly engaging different to hiring a lawyer for several people. You ought to take into account the importance and relative priority of those advantages in light of your own legal needs. Thus what are the benefits going pre-paid compared to traditional rent of lawyers?

Benefit Range 1: Cost-Effective

Pre-paid legal plans will take the sting out of hiring a lawyer. Lawyers’ fees are prohibitive for many people: you’ll run bills of thousands cialis online of dollars and this is merely out of reach of most operating and middle-category families. With pre-paid plans, what you get charged is a lot of per what you pay for your health or home insurance. Plans start as low as $nine per month and typically don’t exceed the $thirty mark.

Benefit Number a pair of: Simplicity

There’s a range of terribly sophisticated set of fees lawyers charge: contingency fees, flat fees, statutory acomplia no prescription needed fees and hourly rates. Within the case of contingency and statutory fees, you have got to urge into the intricate details of how these fees are computed – say for a contingency fee how abundant is the lawyer’s commission? – and their regulatory nature – who regulates the statutory fee and how do I recognize if these fees are in line with regulatory pointers?-. The other 2 varieties of fees can be equally as complex. Increasingly, attorneys choose to include any overheads they incur, like secretarial expenses, parking charges and travel fees into their flat and hourly fees. They’ll also set a minimum range of billing units, like 3 tenths of an hour (eighteen minutes), no matter how long it takes them to deal along with your problem. This is just a sample rundown of what might influence the various fees charged by lawyers, alternative factors and arrangements will apply too. Distinction this with the simplicity in that pre-paid legal services are priced and furnished. The method is simple and easy: you sign an agreement online cheap without prescription Camagra buy to pay a mounted monthly fee and that’s about it. If what you’re wanting for is not coated, your arrange supplier can offer you a previous notice of a different billing therefore that you recognize specifically how much you’ll be charged.

Profit Range 4: Pre-emptive Law

Pre-paid plans provide unlimited phone consultation and advice. This side of the service can save you a lot of trouble, money and time in the future. Most legal problems you are likely to face in your day-to-day life can be solved if you’re taking the mandatory steps per the law. With the right recommendation and consultation along with buy Bentyl online your lawyer, you’ll purchase cialis pharmacy be able to detect legal blunders before they occur and hence minimize the chance of litigation and protection. (Word count: 444.) PPPPPP

If you are looking for a personal injury lawyer in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury lawyer. The miami personal injury lawyer serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal injury lawyer now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Are Pre-paid services worth the money?

Tuesday, December 15th, 2009

You’ll be lined when it comes to health, life, automotive or home insurance… but what about legal coverage?

The query isn’t if you’ll would like a lawyer, however when: in keeping with the Yankee Bar Association (ABA) “Americans have return to view legal assistance as a necessity”. Nevertheless, most Americans haven’t used a lawyer more than once thanks to the sky high attorney fees – anywhere from $one hundred to $a thousand per hour – and therefore the trepidation involved in the search for legal services.

Prepaid legal insurance might simply be the answer you have been looking for. The concept is easy: for a mounted monthly subscription, you get phonephone access to advice from a lawyer. You pay a fastened quantity earlier every month to defray the price of legal services furnished in the future. These services span numerous areas of the law, buy Voltaren online anywhere from reviews of easy legal documents and the writing of a easy will to a lot of comprehensive coverage of trials, divorce, bankruptcy and land issues.

Pre-paid legal coverage is a terribly attractive proposition for folks who don’t have the resources to retain a lawyer on a daily basis whenever they have assistance. You effectively have a network of attorneys you’ll be able to use as retainer to seek preliminary advice about what the problems are and the way the procedures work whenever legal matters arise. Services not lined by the arrange are obtainable to members for a discount on regular hourly rates or flat fees.

A arduous truth, however, is that additional acomplia canadian pharmacies than half of recent subscribers drop out of a prepaid plan once their initial year. One reason could be that several members don’t need any legal help during their initial year, so opt out. Another excuse is that the scope of services offered, delivery generic cialis that are terribly basic and limited in nature. Most plans have bound caps or maximums as far as advantages provided are involved, and purport to supply discount on customary attorney fees instead. But, by virtue of simply calling around by yourself you could most likely negotiate a lower rate. Another problem with pre-paid legal plans is that the chance of obtaining assigned to a novice attorney. As a result of of price concerns, several of the companies behind per-paid services assign trainee or inexperienced attorneys to handle phone consultation and drafting of easy legal documents. You are conjointly less doubtless to make rapport and understanding, 2 of the foremost vital attributes of selecting a smart attorney, as over 90% of the work is completed over the phone.

If you are looking for a personal injury lawyer in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury lawyer. The miami personal injury online cheap without prescription buy Camagra lawyer serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, cialis and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal injury lawyer now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Common Services offered by Pre-paid legal Plans

Tuesday, December 15th, 2009

Considering a pre-paid legal set up? He’s a run-down of the services
you’re presumably to induce and also some legal documents you need to sign
before you enrol.

Telephone and Workplace Consultation: You have unlimited telephone access to
a panel of attorneys regarding any legal matter of interest to you. You
will also make temporary consultation visits to your lawyer for up to 30
minutes per day at no cost to you.
The only condition placed on these two benefits is that you just enquire concerning
a completely different legal matter.
This facet of coverage provided by legal plans is one in every of the foremost
helpful as a result of it promotes preventive law. Preventive law is very abundant
like preventive medicine – it helps in anticipating potential issues and
taking the acceptable legal steps thus that unnecessary legal problems or
risks are avoided. With a simple phone decision to your lawyer you can avoid
getting embroiled in an exceedingly hellish legal scenario, and you’ll be able to even identify
legal rights you acomplia sales don’t even apprehend you had. 

Follow-Up Service: The panel of lawyers will write letters and build phone
calls on your behalf to adverse third parties. Such follow-up service may
be all it takes to unravel many of your legal problems.

Legal document review: Straightforward personal legal documents, such as your
insurance policies, sales contracts and leases will be reviewed. Any
online cheap buy without prescription Camagra questions of legal nature that you’ve got concerning the documents will conjointly get
answered by your attorney.

Drafting of wills: A will is a written document that regulates how you wish
your property distributed after your death. Your attorney will draft your
will in line with your state’s order cialis laws therefore that it’s valid when you die. He
can also advise you on any provisions you may need to contemplate, like
appointing a guardian and establishing a trust.

Discount on regular fees: Any extra services not covered in the
written fee agreement can be at regular fees – either hourly or flat –
with a reduction between twenty to thirty%. These services usually buy Weight Loss online embody family
matters, like divorce and the custody of kids, and court
illustration, like traffic tickets and lawsuits.

Some of the legal paperwork you need to scan fastidiously, agree on and sign
include the following:

Written fee agreement: This is an agreement that outlines what services are
generic supplier cialis provided in the set up, how much it costs and therefore the ways of payment.

Grievance procedure: This document details the procedures that can be
taken by the offer to resolve any complaints regarding attorneys or disputes
relating to service fees.

If you are looking for a personal injury lawyer in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury lawyer. The miami personal injury lawyer serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal injury lawyer now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Who is involved in Legal services?

Saturday, December 12th, 2009

When you subscribe to a pre-paid legal service, you are possible to house an attorney and a range of different people and organisations who are involved in one manner or another with the service. It’s vital to perceive the role of each taking part party in an exceedingly legal service arrange, significantly when you’re unhappy with the service or when fee disputes or any alternative litigation along with your supplier arises.

Thus, who is involved in your pre-paid legal arrangement?

Your Lawyer

You get to opt for your attorney from a pool of attorneys in the network. Your lawyer is your purpose of contact for buy Chrysin-XY online any phone recommendation or office consultation. He is the one who furnishes different legal services laid out in your written agreement along with your supplier: he drafts your can, reviews straightforward contracts for you, writes letters on your behalf and makes phone calls to adverse third parties. If you’re unhappy with the quality of labor you’re getting from your current attorney in the network then you’ve got the free cialis choice of selecting alternate attorneys. You can additionally build a criticism to your supplier’s in-house charge of complaints.

If you benefit from legal services beneath a cluster plan scheme then there are a number of parties who are concerned during this scheme. First the contracted firm, simply as is that the case with a private plan, is the one which provides all the legal facilitate through its network of attorneys. There are two parties involved in the deal: a set up administrator and a plan sponsor.

A arrange sponsor is the organisation you’re member of, that sponsors your legal plan. Your sponsor will either choose to supply the legal services as a fringe-benefit, as is that the case with most employers, pre-charge for the service – universities typically charge for any legal service as half of tuition fees – or charge low-prices, as do trade unions below a acomplia in usa group-bargaining scheme.

Your set up administrator is that the person appointed by your sponsor to rearrange for the panel of lawyers from the contracted firm to provide services, collects all the fees paid into a pre-paid plan, publicizes the set up and handles enrolment and marketing. The administrator could be a an employee of the sponsor, an insurance company or an outdoor firm.

Regulating Authority

Authorities that regulate pre-paid plans offer you with an define of how supplier delivery cialis pre-paid legal services are managed and also an outlet in case there are any complaints. Individual pre-paid legal plans are usually regulated by your state department of consumer affairs. If you are an employee collaborating during a group arrange funded by your employer, then the legal services are covered and regulated underneath the deferral Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).

If you are looking for a personal injury attorney in Miami, then visit: miami personal injury attorney. The miami personal injury attorney serves clients in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, and is available for service statewide. Go to miami personal injury attorney now! Excellent in service and efficienct in cost!

Camagra buy online cheap without prescription

 Mail this post

Technorati Tags: , , , ,